When asked if there can be more than one COVID-19 vaccine, Dan Barouch, MD, PhD (Center for Virology and Vaccine Research, BIDMC) says we need multiple vaccines to be successful.
The Cut – December 1, 2020
So When Exactly Will a COVID Vaccine Be Ready?
Vaccine development is a typically lengthy process: Under normal circumstances, it can take anywhere between a decade and 15 years to get one approved and on the market, ready for distribution. But when epidemiologists began to raise the alarm in January over a new worrying virus that was ravaging a sprawling Chinese capital, it became evident that we were not facing normal circumstances, and drug companies responded accordingly. Now, less than a year after embarking on the frenzied race to develop a safe and effective COVID-19 vaccine, it appears likely that not just one, but multiple vaccines may be ready in the U.S. this month.
So far, two major U.S. pharmaceutical companies have formally applied to the Food and Drug Administration for emergency-use authorization: Pfizer and Moderna, both of which have developed vaccines with efficacy rates hovering around 95 percent, according to final analyses. And then, there’s a third vaccine from British-Swedish pharmaceutical company AstraZeneca, which reported last week that its COVID-19 vaccine was up to 90 percent effective. However, some public-health experts and journalists have since poked holes in this last vaccine’s data, and in at least one instance, called it “shaky.”
Here, everything you need to know.
What vaccines are out there?
While researchers around the world are currently testing 34 vaccines on humans, according to planning documents circulated by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, there are two that are close to being approved in the U.S.:
Pfizer: On November 9, Pfizer— which partnered with German drugmaker BioNTech — announced that its vaccine was more than 90 percent effective at preventing COVID-19 infection in those who have not previously contracted the virus, according to an early analysis. (The vaccine consists of two injections spaced 21 days apart.) Then, on November 18, the company announced the results of their final analysis: Their vaccine was 95 percent effective at preventing mild and serious COVID-19 cases, and produced no serious side effects. Crucially, the New York Times reports that the vaccine is 94 percent effective in older adults who are more susceptible to serious infection and don’t always respond well to vaccines. On November 20, Pfizer applied to the FDA for emergency use authorization.
Moderna: On November 16, Moderna — which is working alongside the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases — announced that its vaccine might be 94.5 percent effective at preventing the coronavirus, per early research. (Among the vaccine’s notable funders: Dolly Parton.) Two weeks later, on November 30, the company announced findings from its final set of data: Its vaccine is 94.1 effective at preventing infection in general, and 100 percent effective at fending off severe infections. The company is now applying for FDA authorization, and hopes to have doses available by the third week of December. (This vaccine consists of two injections four weeks apart.)
And there’s a third vaccine — this one from AstraZeneca, which partnered with the University of Oxford. On November 23, the British-Swedish pharmaceutical company reported that an early analysis showed their vaccine — which is easier to store and more affordable than the previous two — is 90 percent effective, if administered in a somewhat unusual way. When volunteers in trials were given a half-dose followed by a full dose a month later, the vaccine was the most effective. When volunteers were given two full doses a month apart, the vaccine was only 62 percent effective. But in the days since, some experts have started to identify some worrying red flags in the data. To name just two: The company’s results are not from a single, large-scale clinical trial, but rather two smaller studies that were not similarly conducted; also, the trials featured few participants over the age of 55, even though older adults are more susceptible to developing severe cases of COVID-19.
And there still will be more vaccines. The U.S. has supply agreements with a handful of other drug companies that have COVID-19 vaccines in clinical trials, including Johnson & Johnson, Sanofi and GSK, and Novavax. And then, there are the vaccines that won’t be available stateside. Whereas the U.S. is focused on domestic distribution, the Washington Post reports that China and Russia are rushing to approve vaccines so they can distribute doses globally. As of late last week, China has reportedly administered an experimental vaccine to 1 million people; Russia, meanwhile, has made multiple announcements over the past few months about approving vaccines, none of which had undergone vigorous testing to ensure their safety and efficacy. (On November 24, Russia announced that one its leading vaccine, the Sputnik V, was shown to be 95 percent effective, according to an interim analysis.)
Can there be more than one COVID-19 vaccine?
Yes. In fact, public-health experts say that’s preferable. “There are 7 billion people in the world, so we need multiple vaccines to be successful. This is not a race of one developer against another developer — this is a global, collaborative effort,” said Dr. Daniel Barouch, director of the Center for Virology and Vaccine Research at Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center. “I probably speak for all the vaccine developers in saying we want all these programs to succeed.”
What remaining hurdles do the leading vaccines need to clear?
Now, the FDA’s vaccine-advisory committee must review the applications to determine whether to authorize the vaccines. On December 10, the committee is scheduled to consider Pfizer’s vaccine; on December 17, they will reconvene to go over Moderna’s application. Then, once given the green light, the companies will prepare for distribution.
However, in a handful of states, vaccines will have to clear a second hurdle: Because public trust in the federal government’s COVID response is exceptionally low, and for good reason, a number of governors have formed committees to vet any vaccine that the FDA authorizes, the New York Times reports. This extra layer of scrutiny hasn’t exactly been met with enthusiasm from the federal government and public-health experts. “Any delay that the state wants to impose will be a delay in getting its citizens — its most vulnerable citizens — vaccines,” Paul Mango, deputy chief of staff for policy at the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, said during a news briefing. “We think it is actually counterproductive for them to talk about this.”
Regarding when the vaccine will be ready: By the end of the year, Pfizer will have about 25 million doses available in the U.S., and Moderna will have 20 million. So, according to current estimates, there should be enough vaccines for about 20 million people to get inoculated. (Again, both vaccines require two doses.) On December 2, New York Governor Andrew Cuomo tweeted that New York expects to receive enough doses of Pfizer’s vaccine to start inoculating 170,000 residents on December 15.
Who will get vaccinated first?
On December 1, an independent panel that’s advising the CDC recommended that the three million people who live and work in longterm-care facilities, as well as the country’s 21 million health-care workers, should be first in line to get vaccinated — guidance that CDC director Robert Redfield will now decide whether or not to formally accept. If Redfield approves and the FDA authorizes the two vaccines, those two groups will receive their first doses in December.
What about children?
Because children’s immune systems don’t respond to vaccines the same way as adults, none of the major pharmaceutical companies have included them in their clinical trials, though most have vocalized their intent to develop a COVID-19 vaccine for kids. (Children are less likely to develop severe cases of COVID-19, hence the early focus on developing a vaccine for adults; however, kids can obviously spread the virus to high-risk groups.) Currently, optimistic timelines have a coronavirus vaccine reaching children by the end of 2021.
What is the distribution timeline for the vaccines?
Starting next year, Pfizer and Moderna are expected to produce a combined 70 million doses each month, according to the Washington Post. In January, health-care workers and patients living in care facilities would receive their second doses; in February and March, people who are over 65 or have preexisting health conditions, as well as essential workers, will be prioritized. But per the New York Times, it’s likely that those who fall outside these vulnerable groups will start to get vaccinated in the spring, as well. If all goes accordingly, most Americans could be vaccinated by the start of summer.
But distribution isn’t going to be easy — especially involving Pfizer’s vaccine. While both Pfizer and Moderna have used groundbreaking mRNA technology, Pfizer’s vaccine has to be stored at a temperature of negative 94 degrees Fahrenheit in specialized deep-freeze “suitcases” that can only be opened twice a day and for no more than 180 seconds at a time. “The reality is there has never been a drug that required storage at this temperature,” Soumi Saha, a director at Premier, which procures supplies for hospitals across the country, told CBS News; administering this vaccine to many millions of people — especially those in rural areas, where the hospitals may not be able to afford the significant cost of procuring and storing these vaccines — will be a “logistical nightmare.”
While Moderna’s vaccine must also be shipped frozen, it can be stored at a temperature between 36 to 46 degrees Fahrenheit. And then there’s AstraZeneca vaccine, which can be stored and transported at normal refrigerated conditions, for a duration of half-a-year.
Now what about cost?
Operation Warp Speed, the Trump administration’s program dedicated to COVID vaccines and treatments, plans to buy doses from the pharmaceutical companies, ensuring that Americans can get vaccinated for free.
So what happens once we’re widely inoculated?
Well, here’s the deflating news: A vaccine is “not going to be a light switch” back to normalcy, Fauci said during a recent appearance on CNN’s State of the Union, elaborating that we’ll likely be wearing masks and social distancing even after the vaccine is widely distributed. “I would recommend to people to not abandon all public-health measures just because you have been vaccinated,” Fauci said, because, even if you get vaccinated and the efficacy rate of the vaccine ends up being 95 percent, there is still a chance — albeit small — that you could get the virus. Also, Fauci has noted in the past, we have to account for those who don’t get vaccinated, either because they lack access or the means to pay for inoculations or because they’re skeptical.
David Ho, a virologist at Columbia University who’s developing monoclonal antibody therapies, echoed Fauci’s estimation, saying we’ll be continuing our precautionary measures for most of next year.